response to "Conflicting Views Between the Gods"

This is a response to Emma’s post entitled “Conflicting Views Between the Gods”.

I agree with you, Emma, that there is an existing hierarchy within the gods. I find that they respect each other’s positions in this system and don’t challenge each other’s roles. I think they are all a part of Odysseus’ journey in some way, whether helping him or bringing him down. The points you brought up are one way to look at the relationship between Athena and Poseidon, but I see it in a different way. I think that the things Poseidon and Athena do to and for Odysseus, whether it is a detriment or assistance, are the ways that they fight with each other. Though I agree with you that they never seem to confront each other, I see that they do indirectly through Odysseus. For example, while following the guidance of Athena on his journey, Poseidon provides the obstacles for Odysseus, both to hurt his progress and to oppose Athena’s actions. I think, also, that Poseidon is mad at Athena for helping Odysseus, because of his ongoing grudge against him, and instead of approaching the goddess, he respects her power and only indirectly harms her.

Another important thing that I get out of this part of the reading is Odysseus rolling with the punches, so to speak. No matter how harshly the gods are fighting over him, he deals with it and just looks for help from those who support him. Specifically, when the storm hits, he just relies on the powers of other gods or beings (Ina, in this case) to help him through.

So, Emma, I add to what you said with this...I believe there is a definite hierarchy and mutual respect between the gods, in that they respect each other’s status and do not deal with their issues one on one. Instead they use Odysseus as a middle-man to see who will come out the most powerful.

Does anyone else have any ideas about this?